Full text of the Rationale for the Award by the Institute for Tourism and Development (Studienkreis für Tourismus und Entwicklung):
TO DO! 2005 |
On behalf of the Institute for Tourism and Development (Studienkreis für Tourismus und Entwicklung) the author travelled to Elim, Ribolla District, Limpopo Province in South Africa, during the period from 17 to 23 November 2005, in order to assess on location the contest entry of KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS. This project was developed together with SKR, Studien Kontakt Reisen from Bonn, Germany, five years ago. Following its successful trial run in practice, it was submitted to the TO DO! 2005 contest.
The assessor recommends that KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS be awarded a TO DO! prize during the ITB 2006, in appreciation of the objectives, the concept and the realisation of its measures. Particular mention should be made of the role of the tour operator SKR, Studien Kontakt Reisen, Bonn, which has supported the regional development programme of KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS from the very beginning, and offers the trip to the region on the German market under the heading "Gesichter Südafrikas"("South Africa's Faces").
The Republic of South Africa has a large potential for tourism. The revenue from tourism grew strongly in the past few years and amounted to US $ 5.2 billion in 2003. Tourism thus contributed 3.3% to the gross national product (GNP). During the period of Apartheid, South Africa's tourism was concentrated mainly in a few "hot spots", with an insignificant impact on the broader economy. The Ministry of Environmental Affairs and Tourism worked on a national tourism strategy from 1994 through 2000. The "Reconstruction and Development" Programme also includes conceptual guidelines for "responsible tourism". According to the guideline, tourism should be shaped in a manner that achieves sustainable effects in the economic, ecological and social fields. "In essence, our approach is that tourism should be government-led, private-sector driven, community-based, people-centred and labour-dependent."
In the following, a few measures that were realized by the authorities as a result of the programme:
Poverty alleviation through tourism is a goal of South Africa's government, which it seems to pursue with emphasis. However, there is a lack of educational training programmes and opportunities in tourism, especially for black South Africans.
The activities of KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS are based in the District of Rimbolla (district capital Makhado, former Louis Trichardt) in the Limpopo Province.
The Limpopo Province lies in the outermost northeast of the country (the capital is Polokwane, former Pietersburg). This province is among the poorer regions with a high illiteracy rate of the adult population and a high level of unemployment. In particular, it is home of the Shangaan and Venda tribes, with their rich and active cultural heritage, which is manifested in legends, stories, dances, music, in traditional medicine and craftsmanship. In general, the people still know where they belong and are not plagued by any doubts regarding their identity.
The potential for tourism in this region has been explored systematically only in the last few years comprising savannah, scrub land, sandstone ridges, and up to 1700-metre-high mountains and mountain ranges. In addition, it has a large number of lakes, rivers and canyons. Such a terrain offers a multitude of opportunities for tourism activity, which the tourism industry is making increasing use of. The diverse wildlife, particularly in Kruger National Park and other nature reserves is of outstanding beauty.
KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS (in the local language "Kuvona" means "see, understand") is actually considered to be an incoming agency / tour operator in the legal sense and is registered with the central government as a closed corporation. However, the actual work comprises more than this. KUVONA strives to bring tourists to the north of the Limpopo Province, to show them the culture of the Venda and Shangaan tribes, to implement a "soft tourism" in partnership with the local communities, as well as to educate and train tourism personnel and to create manifold employment opportunities. From 1995 to 2000, structures were developed, and artists and craftsmen, as well as key institutions and individuals in tourism, were identified. The tourism potential carried by the communities was analysed and a lot of personnel was trained. Currently about 80% of KUVONA's activities take place exclusively in the Limpopo Province. However, the enterprise also uses the potential of the Ivory Route and Kruger National Park, and takes groups of tourists into Zimbabwe, Botswana and Namibia. Generally, travellers of the tour operator SKR make use of these offers. A smaller share of the customers is comprised of individual tourists or come from other tour operators.
In 1998, the white South Africans Eric (father) and Paul (son) Girardin, who at the time were owners and operators of the SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE in Elim, recognised that they did not work profitably. A "high volume - low income" situation existed. This is how the plan to establish a business branch and to actively engage in professional marketing was developed. In 1999, the first partnership agreement was concluded with SKR, Studien Kontakt Reisen in Germany, which had already worked with the Lodge prior to that time. SKR announced its intention to cooperate on a long-term basis. This in particular gave Paul Girardin the courage to finally implement his ideas in the form of a new enterprise called KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS.
The work of KUVONA is supported by a network that has continuously developed in the past ten years. Locally, the main members of the network are the SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE and the tourism organisation RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION (RTA).
The unofficial name "Kuvona Cultural Association" is occasionally used as a collective name for all three organisations. Within their abilities, the three enterprises together contribute to the development of the region with the help of tourism. In the source countries of the travellers, the tour operator Studien Kontakt Reisen (SKR) in Bonn, Germany, with its two-week journey "Gesichter Südafrikas" ("South Africa's Faces") is responsible for a large share of the success of KUVONA's tourism programmes. The entry of the tour operator into the unknown region enabled establishing the first successful tour already in the year 2000. In 2005, 101 tourists with a total of 14 travel groups visited the programmes of KUVONA; 72 travellers from Germany came through SKR. For 2006, the programme has already been booked by 210 tourists in 22 groups.
From the very start, the Girardin family acted as a catalyst in the development on site. Paul and Michel Girardin are fluent in the language of the indigenous people. Furthermore, both went through highly qualified tourism training.
SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE
Eric Girardin and his son Paul Girardin founded the "SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE" in Elim at the Albasini reservoir as early as 1995. In the local language SHILUVARI means "wild pear". It is also registered with the central government as a closed corporation, and offers lodging for 28 people. The lodge was built by unskilled local craftsmen. Concurrent to this, from the very beginning, Eric Girardin supported an 'Artist Association' (wood carvers, potters and embroiderers) in Elim and the surrounding area, and brought tourists in contact with the association. The lodge was used mainly by the guests of the tour "Gesichter Südafrikas" ("South Africa's Faces"), which is offered through Studien Kontakt Reisen. In 1997, Eric Giradin climbed the approximately 1100 metre-high Ribolla Mountain. In the local language "Ribolla" means "bee stinger". Overwhelmed by the panorama of the vast landscape with the villages embedded in it, he developed the idea of a working community for the region, into which the indigenous population should be firmly integrated. Subsequently, the 'Artist Association' was renamed into the "RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION".
RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATON (RTA)
RTA was registered as a non-profit organisation in Polokwane (Pietersburg). In the meantime RTA has over 200 members. Unfortunately, only 55 members pay their annual fees. The annual fees are ranked according to different categories: enterprises, such as lodges and hotels pay 500 Rand (100 Rand correspond to about € 13.80), artisan groups pay 300 Rand and an additional 10 Rand per group member, drummer and dance groups pay 100 Rand, and individual persons also pay 100 Rand. In addition, certain percentages of the proceeds of the RTA tour guides and the sale of handicraft products are paid into the account of the Association. There were also regular contributions from different institutions and individuals.
The SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE and RTA profited from one another from the very beginning: RTA was able to offer many cultural attractions to the SHILUVARI tourists. In return, SHILUVARI helped RTA by purchasing handcrafted products, through educational measures and by providing financial support for the tour guides. Nowadays, all KUVONA tourists are accommodated at the SHILUVARI LODGE. In addition, due to the mutual memberships and different measures for mutual support, but also on the basis of the ownership situation, all three enterprises maintain close contacts.
Paul Girardin's share in KUVONA amounts to 50%. The black South African Abel Baloyi holds 20% and Paul's brother Michel holds 30%.
KUVONA holds no shares in the SHILUVARI LODGE, but uses the lodge to accommodate its tourists within the framework of an agreement. Since November 2005 there is also a letter of intent between KUVONA and RIBOLLA TOURIMS ASSOCIATION (RTA). SHILUVARI and KUVONA are members of RTA.

In the following rationale for the recommended award, the main focus has been placed on KUVONA. Since the work of KUVONA, as described above, is strongly linked together with the work of other enterprises, the SHILUVARI LODGE was also included in the analysis in partial aspects. The certification with a "Fair Trade in Tourism Trademark" provided grounds for hope that the relevant TO DO! criteria are also fulfilled there. This certificate is awarded by the tourism organisation "Fair Trade in Tourism South Africa" (FTTSA) in Pretoria. It was not possible to assess the work of RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION (RTA) with regard to concept, activities, internal structures and decision-making processes.
In view of the short stay of the assessor at the location, it was only possible to check the fulfilment of the contest criteria within the District of Ribolla. The events offered outside this area, in the Kruger National Park, along the "Ivory Route", in Zimbabwe, Botswana and Namibia, could not be personally inspected.
Assessing the activities of KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS with the eight TO DO! criteria for socially responsible tourism leads to the following valuation:
| Involving of the different interests and requirements of the local people through participation |
KUVONA is the result of a process, in which the local population was involved from the very beginning, since the founding of the SHILUVARI LODGE in 1995, and is increasingly being involved at present. The vision of KUVONA is that one day the RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION (which is primarily carried by black South Africans) will also have a second development "pillar" in the form of their own tourism enterprise.
A position statement of RTA/KUVONA says: "We have to develop tourism in close partnership with the rural communities in order to avoid imposing international tourism on the people."
|
Strengthening the awareness among the local people with regard to the chances and risks of tourism development in their everyday economic, social and cultural life |
The local people are aware of the economic chances and risks to their region associated with the emergence of tourism. Just two years after the formation of the 'Artist Association', the organisation was renamed into "Ribolla Tourism Association". In addition to the approximately 200 members, family members are also being brought into the projects.
| Participation of broad local population strata regarding the positive economic, social and cultural effects of tourism. |
The association of KUVONA with RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION is a very important factor for the RTA members with regard to their economic existence. KUVONA brings tourists and therefore income for the RTA members, and as far as they are involved in activities, for their extended families.
| Guarantee of the attractiveness of jobs in tourism for the local people by improving working conditions in relation to payment, social security, working hours, education and training |
SHILUVARI, KUVONA and RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION (RTA) are closely interlocked with each other. At this point we will therefore not only go into the KUVONA's achievement with respect to the aforementioned criterion but will also consider the contribution of the two other enterprises to this aspect of tourism development.
| Reinforcement of the local culture as well as the cultural identity of those living in tourism destination areas |
| Avoidance or minimisation of social and cultural damage caused by tourism in destination areas |
KUVONA nurtures a respectful and partnership like interaction with the people involved in the development of tourism in the region.
| Projects and measures entered into the contest must be in line with the principles of environmental compatibility |
As portrayed, KUVONA uses the SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE for the duration of their guests' stay in the Ribolla region. The lodge offers overnight accommodation for 28 people. The lodge, restaurant and conference hall are located in a nature preserve at the Albasini reservoir (which serves as a drinking water reservoir and for irrigation). The lodge is managed in conformity with the principles of socially responsible and therefore also environmentally compatible tourism development. For this reason, the SHILUVARI LODGE was happy about being awarded the certificate "Fair Trade in Tourism South Africa" of the FTTSA as the very first enterprise to receive such a certificate in South Africa.
| Implementation of measures or mechanisms which can guarantee the economic and institutional sustainability of the project |
From an economic perspective, the sustainability of KUVONA appears to be assured. The number of arrivals increases yearly, particularly due to the good cooperation with SKR Studien Kontakt Reisen and a Dutch travel operator.
Although the most important representatives of RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION, SHILUVARI und KUVONA live on the same grounds and could exchange information without any difficulties, the assessor recommends that a formal "Round Table" should be established. The participants should meet on a regular basis in order to communicate and coordinate their decisions. However, it should be possible that internal decisions pertaining to one particular enterprise can be taken independently. The managing director and the marketing expert of RTA should also sit at this "Round Table."
KUVONA lacks a structured monitoring and evaluation system (M+E), which enables recorded assessments of the individual activities and their costs, as well as of the impacts of the measures taken, and ensures regular controlling. (This was already proposed by FTTSA). Such a system could also be used by RTA. Furthermore the M+E could provide new insights into the effects the different donations by institutions and tourists have on the recipients.
Until now the relations between KUVONA and RTA were not formalised but were based on oral agreements for the most part. With the "letter of intent" a first step to a stronger planning security for both sides was taken. This should be continued and be wrapped up in a contractual relationship.
Comments regarding the contentment of guests could for example be recorded with the help of a questionnaire in the rooms of the lodge in order to obtain valuable advice on the further development of services being offered.
KUVONA CULTURAL TOURS in cooperation with SHILUVARI LAKESIDE LODGE, RIBOLLA TOURISM ASSOCIATION (RTA) and with SKR Studien Kontakt Reisen in Germany succeeded in developing a holistic tourism approach. The development of tourism so far is consistent with the conceptual specifications for "Responsible Tourism" and the aims of the "Reconstruction and Development Program" of the government of South Africa. KUVONA offers individual, special and general possibilities for education and further training. Many actors take part in the implementation of the programme, and a lot of people benefit from it.
In addition to providing employment and continuing education and training for indigenous staff, special features of the project are to be found in the cautious encounter with the culture and way of life of the Shangaan and Venda peoples, environmental-conscious conduct, and economic promotion of as many people as possible within and outside the institutions and enterprises cooperating with KUVONA.
| Addresses |
| in South Africa: | in Germany: |
| Kuvona Cultural Tours | SKR, Studien Kontakt Reisen |
| Abel Baloyi Angelika Girardin | Luise Müller |
| P. O. Box 56 | Kurfürstenallee 5 |
| Louis Trichardt 0920 North. Prov., South Africa | 53177 Bonn |
| Tel.: +27-15-556 35 | Tel.: +49-228-93573-0 |
| Fax: +27-15-556 35 12 | Fax.: +49-228-93573-50 |
| E-Mail: kuvona@mweb.co.za | E-Mail: info@skr.de |
| Web: www.kuvona.com | Web: www.skr.de |
Organiser of the TO DO! 2005 Contest Socially Responsible Tourism:
Institute for Tourism and Development (Institut für Tourismus und Entwicklung)
Kapellenweg 3, D-82541 Ammerland/Starnberger See
Tel. +49-(0)8177-1783, Fax: +49-(0)8177-1349
E-Mail: info@studienkreis.org
| Websites: | www.studienkreis.org |
| www.to-do-contest.org | |
| www.tourador-contest.org | |
| www.sympathiemagazin.de |
In cooperation with:
German Federal Ministry for Economic Co-operation and Development (BMZ)
German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety (BMU)
Ecumenical Coalition on Tourism
Europäische Reiseversicherung AG
German Church World Service e.V. (EED) - Tourism Watch
Catholic Foreign Secretariat of the German Bishops' Conference
Messe Berlin GmbH
Vasco - Die gute Reise
Top ![]() |